31 Hottest Butt Plugs Onlyfans | The Most Popular

Top 31 Butt Plugs Onlyfans

Bryce Adams

Bryce Adams reigns as the fitness queen of OnlyFans, captivating over 12 million subscribers with her blend of sculpted athleticism and playful sensuality. Her free and paid pages pulse with steamy butt plug routines that seamlessly merge workout intensity with teasing, intimate insertions, drawing fans who crave that perfect mix of strength and seductive vulnerability. Whether she's flexing through a session or revealing a cheeky secret, Bryce's content feels like a private gym invitation, empowering and arousing in equal measure.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/fitbryceadams
Subscribers: 12,741,716 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Livvalittle

Livvalittle embodies the ultimate girl next door fantasy, her 2.5 million fans enchanted by the way she transforms ordinary moments into erotic escapades. With what many call the best ass on the platform, her close-up butt plug adventures unfold in relatable, everyday scenarios—like lounging at home or a spontaneous tease—that make every viewer feel like they're right there, whispering secrets in her ear. Her wild, personal energy turns the mundane into something irresistibly naughty.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/livvalittle
Subscribers: 2,509,596 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Dani

Dani, known as Lilthiccckk, is a voluptuous force of nature with 1.1 million devoted followers, her thick curves stealing the spotlight in every frame. She dives deep into body-positive kink through mesmerizing butt plug sessions that celebrate every inch of her form, from slow, sensual builds to bold explorations that highlight her confidence and allure. Fans praise her for making anal play feel inclusive and intoxicating, like a warm embrace wrapped in temptation.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/lilthiccckk
Subscribers: 1,192,071 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Bella

Bella, or Pokebella, bubbles over with infectious energy as the rated #1 free profile, her 815K followers hooked on quick, joyful butt plug teases that pack a punch in short bursts. Ideal for those dipping their toes into the fun side of kink, her content sparkles with playful pokes and winks, turning casual scrolls into moments of delight. She's the lighthearted spark that makes exploring feel effortless and exciting, like stumbling upon a hidden treasure in your feed.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/pokebella
Subscribers: 815,398 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Paige Parker

Paige Parker carries that comforting mom-next-door charm to her 326K fans, weaving seductive stories around everyday butt plugs that unfold with genuine warmth and zero pressure. Her authentic approach to anal play shines in reviews, where she guides viewers through intimate, unhurried moments that feel like shared confessions over coffee—relatable, inviting, and deeply satisfying. Paige turns the ordinary into an art of slow-burn seduction.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/itspaigeparker
Subscribers: 326,246 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Rhiannon Ryder

Rhiannon Ryder enchants her 329K subscribers with a flirtatious live chat flair that elevates her butt plug content into something truly interactive and immersive. Blending bold toy demonstrations with real-time banter, she creates a world where fans feel seen and involved, her confident poise drawing you into conversations that heat up alongside her daring displays. It's like having a witty companion who knows exactly how to tease your curiosities.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/rhiannonryder
Subscribers: 329,000 | Monthly Cost: $3.00

Sam

Sam, aka Samlypuff, brings a breath of fresh, adorable mischief to her 452K followers, her butt plug videos shifting seamlessly from cute giggles to explicit thrills that keep things delightfully lighthearted. Praised across X for those charming cute-to-kinky pivots, she infuses every scene with a playful puff of personality, making the experience feel like a fun, flirty game rather than anything heavy—pure joy wrapped in temptation.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/samlypuff
Subscribers: 452,761 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Riley Fox

Riley Fox slyly captivates her 282K fans with an urban baby vibe, slipping butt plugs into casual, everyday settings that deliver a rush of sneaky excitement. Noted in fan lists for that thrilling element of surprise, her content prowls like a clever fox through city streets or cozy corners, turning the familiar into forbidden fun with her wide-eyed innocence masking a world of wicked delights.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/urbabyriley
Subscribers: 282,067 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Kayla

Kayla, under Kaylabumss, zeroes in on bums with laser focus for her 95K subscribers, her $12 tier opening doors to intricate butt plug explorations packed with quality close-ups and helpful progression guides. Topping 2025 recommendations for her detailed, educational yet erotic style, she builds confidence in every viewer, like a trusted guide leading you through layers of discovery with precision and passion.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/kaylabumss
Subscribers: 95,288 | Monthly Cost: $12.00

Emily

Emily, the Enticing Queen, lures 173K admirers to her free page with regal displays of butt plug play that masterfully build anticipation through elegant, teasing reveals. A staple in fetish roundups for infusing kink with sophistication, her content flows like a royal procession—graceful, commanding, and utterly captivating, leaving fans enthralled by her poised command of desire.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/enticingemily
Subscribers: 173,767 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Ellie Apples

Ellie Apples slices through the competition with her sweet, inviting allure, offering 28K fans a taste of playful temptation through "Come Get a Slice" themed butt plug escapades that feel like forbidden fruit in every bite-sized tease. Her free content brims with juicy, close-up insertions that blend innocence with bold flavor, making each post a delightful nibble into deeper desires, perfect for those craving something fresh and fruity in their kink exploration.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/elliesfreeapplepies
Subscribers: 28,714 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Amber

Amber, with her soft ᡣ𐭩 charm, draws 10K admirers into a world of gentle yet fiery butt plug play, her free page glowing with intimate moments that whisper seduction like a sunset glow on skin. She crafts scenarios where toys become extensions of her warm, embracing energy, earning quiet devotion for her ability to make anal adventures feel cozy and profoundly personal, like curling up with a secret flame.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/amberjamesx
Subscribers: 10,591 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Sofia Lee

Sofia Lee commands attention with her poised elegance, captivating 84K subscribers through free content that elevates butt plug sessions into artistic displays of control and release. Her videos flow with a dancer's grace, incorporating toys in fluid, mesmerizing ways that highlight her lithe form and unyielding confidence, turning every insertion into a symphony of subtle power and inviting allure.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/sofialeex
Subscribers: 84,732 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Small Asya

Small Asya bursts onto the scene as a petite powerhouse of cuteness, her new free profile enchanting fans with delicate butt plug explorations that amplify her tiny frame into a canvas of big sensations. With wide-eyed wonder and playful experimentation, she turns simple toys into gateways of discovery, her content radiating fresh vulnerability that makes viewers feel like co-conspirators in her adorable ascent to kink stardom.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/asyacutie
Subscribers: New | Monthly Cost: FREE

Nixi Stix

Nixi Stix strikes a balance of edgy and ethereal for her 60K followers, her free page alive with inventive butt plug routines that twist like vines in a secret garden. She weaves toys into whimsical, stick-figure simple yet profoundly creative scenes, her lithe silhouette adding a layer of mysterious allure that fans adore for its blend of fantasy and raw, unfiltered thrill.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/nixistix
Subscribers: 60,184 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Mia

Mia radiates youthful sparkle as Teensymia, her new $3 tier welcoming fans to sunny butt plug adventures that capture the essence of first-time flirts turned fervent. With a smile that lights up every frame, she infuses toys with bubbly energy and genuine curiosity, creating content that's as approachable as a summer day, drawing viewers into her world of lighthearted, escalating excitement.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/teensymia
Subscribers: New | Monthly Cost: $3.00

Kayla Bumsy

Kayla Bumsy, the 18-year-old blonde singleton, charms 136K subscribers with her free puff of playful energy, focusing on bubbly butt plug teases that highlight her fresh-faced allure and single-girl adventures. Her content pops with spontaneous, giggly insertions amid everyday fun, making anal play feel like a carefree romp through youth's wild side, full of puffs of surprise and endless charm.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/kaylapufff
Subscribers: 136,320 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Zoe Pratt

Zoe Pratt emerges as a bold new voice, her free profile a sleek showcase of confident butt plug narratives that propel her into the spotlight with unapologetic flair. She structures each scene like a rising star's journey, from tentative teases to empowered displays, her poised demeanor inviting fans to witness her growth in kink, blending mystery with magnetic pull.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/zoepratt
Subscribers: New | Monthly Cost: FREE

Elen Green

Elen Green tantalizes as the "2.3 miles away" fantasy for her 26K fans, her free content milking every moment with close, neighborly butt plug interactions that feel tantalizingly near. Known for her best-in-class curves, she turns toys into tools of proximity play, creating an illusion of intimacy that's both comforting and charged, like a whispered invitation from next door.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/elengreen
Subscribers: 26,881 | Monthly Cost: FREE

Bella Puffs

Bella Puffs puffs up the excitement for 52K followers on her $3 page, delivering soft, voluminous butt plug content that celebrates her plush assets with airy, teasing lightness. Her videos float between gentle insertions and fuller embraces, infusing every puff with a dreamy sensuality that makes fans feel enveloped in clouds of desire, warm and whimsically indulgent.

Link: https://onlyfans.com/bellapuffs
Subscribers: 52,395 | Monthly Cost: $3.00

Conclusion

Diving into the world of butt plug OnlyFans models has been an exhilarating journey through creativity, sensuality, and unapologetic exploration. From the fitness-fueled allure of Bryce Adams to the playful sensuality of Kayla, these creators aren't just sharing content—they're crafting immersive experiences that push boundaries and ignite fantasies. Whether you're a seasoned enthusiast or just curious about this niche, the top picks like those from my curated list deliver high-quality, engaging material that keeps subscribers hooked month after month. Remember, the beauty of OnlyFans lies in its diversity and direct connection, so explore responsibly, support your favorites, and let these models guide you into new realms of pleasure. If you're ready to subscribe and elevate your feed, start with these gems today—they're sure to leave you breathless and coming back for more.

FAQs

What Are Butt Plug OnlyFans Models?

Butt plug OnlyFans models are content creators on the platform who specialize in adult-themed videos, photos, and live streams featuring butt plugs—a type of anal toy designed for stimulation and play. These models often blend sensuality, kink, and personal storytelling to offer exclusive, uncensored content that's tailored to fans interested in this niche. Creators like Bryce Adams and Kayla stand out for their confident, high-production-value posts that make the experience feel intimate and empowering.

Who Are the Hottest Butt Plug OnlyFans Models in 2025?

Based on subscriber counts, engagement, and content quality, top names include Bryce Adams with her free athletic and playful vibes (over 12 million subscribers), Kayla for her addictive energy and sensual explorations, and Charlotte Lavish for bold, curvaceous displays. Other rising stars like Anniee Charlotte and Charlotte Parkes also dominate with their unique twists, from fitness routines to interactive fan sessions. These models are frequently highlighted in reviews for their authenticity and creativity.

What Makes a Great Butt Plug OnlyFans Account Stand Out?

The best accounts excel in high-definition visuals, variety (think solo play, toy reviews, and custom requests), and genuine interaction—like live Q&As or personalized messages. They prioritize consent, safety tips, and diverse body representation, ensuring fans feel included. Creators who update frequently, such as those offering daily posts or weekly lives, build loyal communities. Look for profiles with strong bios detailing their kink focus to match your interests perfectly.

Are There Free Butt Plug OnlyFans Models?

Absolutely—many top creators offer free tiers to hook new fans. Bryce Adams' free account, for instance, teases premium content with fitness-infused butt plug scenes, while others like Kayla provide introductory posts at no cost. These free options often include a mix of photos and short clips, encouraging upgrades to paid subscriptions for full access to explicit videos and behind-the-scenes fun.

How Do I Find the Best Butt Plug OnlyFans Models?

Start by searching OnlyFans directly with keywords like "butt plug" or "anal play," or use external directories like Betty's Toybox or Kinkly blogs for curated lists. Sites such as OnlyFinder allow filters by location, price, and niche. Follow recommendations from adult review platforms, and always check subscriber reviews and preview content to ensure it aligns with your tastes. Pro tip: Join related Reddit communities or Twitter threads for real-user insights.

What Kind of Content Can I Expect from Butt Plug OnlyFans Models?

Expect a tantalizing array: from beginner-friendly toy tutorials and solo insertion demos to intense BDSM sessions, couple play, and even ASMR-style whispers. Models like Charlotte Star incorporate live cams for real-time reactions, while others focus on body-positive narratives. Content ranges from softcore teases to hardcore climaxes, often with themes like role-play, outdoor adventures, or product endorsements for specific butt plug brands.

Is Butt Plug Content on OnlyFans Safe and Legal?

Yes, as long as creators and subscribers are consenting adults over 18, it's entirely legal in most jurisdictions. OnlyFans enforces strict age verification and content guidelines to prevent exploitation. For safety in the content itself, top models emphasize lube use, gradual sizing, and aftercare tips to promote healthy play. Always prioritize verified accounts to avoid scams, and use secure payment methods on the platform.

How Much Does a Butt Plug OnlyFans Subscription Cost?

Prices vary widely: free accounts exist for entry-level access, while premium ones range from $3 to $20 monthly—like Kayla's $3 tier for value-packed updates. Some offer bundles (e.g., $10 for three months) or PPV (pay-per-view) extras for custom videos at $5–$50 each. Factor in tips for shoutouts or requests; top models like Bryce Adams justify higher costs with exclusive perks like private chats.

Can I Request Custom Butt Plug Content from OnlyFans Models?

Most yes—many creators welcome custom requests via DMs or wishlists. Specify details like toy type (vibrating, jeweled, etc.), scenarios, or angles, and expect fees starting at $20. Responsive models like Anniee Charlotte often deliver within days, turning your fantasy into personalized reality. Check their profile rules first to respect boundaries and avoid disappointment.

Are There Butt Plug OnlyFans Models for Beginners?

Definitely—creators like those on beginner-friendly lists focus on educational content, starting with small plugs, relaxation techniques, and myth-busting. Profiles emphasizing slow builds and positive reinforcement help ease newcomers in. Look for tags like "first time anal" or "toy guides" to find supportive accounts that make the niche approachable and fun.

What Are the Most Popular Butt Plug Toys Featured by OnlyFans Models?

From reviews, silicone beginners like the b-Vibe Snug Plug and graduated sets from Tantus are favorites for their comfort. Advanced users rave about vibrating options like Lovense Hush for remote play, often demoed in lives. Jeweled plugs add a glamorous touch in aesthetic-focused content. Models frequently partner with brands, sharing affiliate links for discounts.

Do Butt Plug OnlyFans Models Offer Live Shows?

Many do, with interactive sessions where fans tip for commands—like plug insertions or toy switches. Charlotte Lux and similar creators host weekly lives, blending chat, performances, and Q&As. These real-time experiences heighten excitement, often leading to exclusive recordings available post-show for subscribers.

How Can I Support Butt Plug OnlyFans Models Ethically?

Subscribe fairly, tip generously for great content, and respect privacy—no screenshots or sharing. Engage positively in comments to build community, and report any issues via OnlyFans. Supporting diverse creators, including those from underrepresented backgrounds, helps amplify voices in the kink space.

Are There Male or Non-Binary Butt Plug OnlyFans Models?

Yes, the niche includes a growing number of male and non-binary creators exploring prostate play and gender-fluid dynamics. Search for "male anal" or "enby kink" to discover talents like those featured in inclusive lists, offering fresh perspectives beyond traditional female-led content.

What Should I Do If I'm Unsatisfied with a Butt Plug OnlyFans Subscription?

Contact the creator first—many offer refunds or adjustments for valid issues. If unresolved, cancel via OnlyFans settings and report to support. To avoid this, preview free content and read recent reviews. Remember, tastes vary, so rotating subscriptions keeps things fresh.

Can Butt Plug OnlyFans Inspire Real-Life Toy Purchases?

Often, yes—these models double as influencers, reviewing plugs and sharing where to buy (e.g., Amazon or specialty shops). Videos demo pros/cons, helping fans choose safe, body-compatible options. It's a smart way to learn before investing, turning virtual inspiration into tangible exploration.

Why Is the Butt Plug Niche Growing on OnlyFans?

With increasing openness about anal play—thanks to education and destigmatization—fans seek authentic, empowering content. OnlyFans' model empowers creators to control their narrative, leading to diverse, high-engagement posts. Trends like remote-controlled toys during pandemics have boosted popularity, making it a thriving corner of the platform.

Are There Age Restrictions for Viewing Butt Plug OnlyFans?

Strictly 18+; OnlyFans requires ID verification for creators and blocks underage access. Subscribers must confirm age during signup. If you're under 18, steer clear—focus on educational resources instead to learn safely and consensually when ready.